San Francisco has by no means been shy about reimagining its streets. From banning vehicles in elements of Golden Gate Park to turning freeway off-ramps into inexperienced area, town has embraced a extra pedestrian-friendly imaginative and prescient lately. Sunset Dunes was speculated to be an emblem of that progress—one other daring rethinking of how San Francisco makes use of its public areas. Constructed on a closed two-mile stretch of the Nice Freeway, the 55-acre park formally opened in April 2025, remodeling what was as soon as a busy commuter route right into a breezy, car-free promenade with sweeping ocean views. However as an alternative of the broad assist metropolis leaders might need hoped for, the venture has sparked frustration, particularly amongst residents of the Sundown District.
Associated
One Of The South’s Most Underrated Parks Is Underground In A City You’d Never Expect
This distinctive website underground is just not what you normally anticipate from a U.S. park, nevertheless it’s nonetheless price a go to.
The anger facilities on what was misplaced to make Sundown Dunes potential. By shutting down the Nice Freeway to vehicles, metropolis planners rerouted 1000’s of day by day drivers onto close by neighborhood streets, resulting in new site visitors bottlenecks, noise complaints, and commuter complications. It was speculated to convey calm and connection to the coast. As an alternative, it’s left some residents offended, divided, and demanding change. Right here’s why some locals are livid.
Why Locals Are Indignant About Sundown Dunes
San Francisco is understood for its quirky, one-of-a-kind spots—think Haight-Ashbury or the colourful 16th Avenue tiled staircase in the Sunset District. However one of many metropolis’s latest quirks, Sundown Dunes, has sparked not pleasure, however outrage. What was meant to be a peaceable stretch of coastal parkland has left some residents livid, and for a lot of, the frustration begins with site visitors. For practically a century, the Nice Freeway served as a significant north-south artery for drivers on San Francisco’s west aspect. When town made it car-free completely in 2025, the choice immediately disrupted commuting routines for 1000’s, creating an instantaneous backlash. Close by streets noticed elevated site visitors, longer commute instances, and added stress for residents who had relied on the freeway for day by day journey.
Some Sundown District residents have misplaced belief in District Supervisor Joel Engardio, who supported the closure and helped put the park on the poll. Critics argue that he campaigned on a compromise—weekend-only closures—however reversed course as soon as elected. The anger has reached such a boiling level that recall papers have been filed, with greater than 11,000 signatures collected. The destiny of Engardio’s political profession now hangs within the stability. Many residents argue that the park merely isn’t price the fee to their day by day lives. “This complete metropolis is anti-car,” stated Alyse Ceirante, a local resident and recall supporter. She, like others, believes the venture sacrificed practicality for a imaginative and prescient not shared by the individuals most affected. Although 55% of voters authorized the closure citywide, precincts closest to the park overwhelmingly voted in opposition to it.
The Imaginative and prescient Behind Sundown Dunes
Visitors on the Nice Freeway in San Francisco, California, CA, USA.
Regardless of the backlash, metropolis leaders and park advocates see Sundown Dunes as a landmark venture—one which reimagines how cities can use city area to prioritize individuals over vehicles. Impressed by pandemic-era car-free zones, the park reclaims oceanfront land for walkers, cyclists, and households, providing a scenic public escape. Supervisor Joel Engardio, whose district consists of the park, has known as it each environmentally accountable and socially transformative. With the southern stretch of the Nice Freeway already closed due to erosion, he framed the park as a inventive answer: “Mom Nature gave us a lemon. We made lemonade.”
Dune Safety Upgrades:
- 50 acres of latest coastal parkland
- Native dunes restored to guard in opposition to erosion and sea stage rise
- Judah Dune Blowout replanted with 1,500 native grasses
- Dune fencing put in to forestall habitat harm
- Challenge supported by volunteers and native environmental teams
Supporters argue the park meets an actual want in a dense a part of town the place inexperienced area is restricted. It’s not only a route—it’s a vacation spot. With a large octopus jungle gymnasium, a motorbike pump observe, and interactive sculptures, the area invitations individuals to linger and join. Native companies are seeing advantages, too, with some reporting gross sales boosts of as much as 35% for the reason that park opened. Whereas critics name it a “conflict on vehicles,” backers say it’s an opportunity to reclaim the coast for everybody, constructing on momentum from the transformation of JFK Drive in Golden Gate Park.
Associated
This City Has America’s Steepest Driveable Street, But It’s Illegal To Drive Down It
Nestled within the hills of Pennsylvania is America’s steepest driveable road in a historic metropolis, and it places San Francisco streets to disgrace
Past recreation, Sundown Dunes additionally goals to revive the shoreline itself. A lot of the previous freeway sat on degraded sand dunes that after shielded town from storms, sea-level rise, and windblown sand. Now these pure defenses are being revived by native plantings, erosion management, and habitat restoration. A pilot venture on the Judah Dune Blowout, guided by the San Francisco Estuary Institute, concerned over 100 volunteers and teams just like the Surfrider Basis and California Academy of Sciences. Collectively, they replanted two acres with native wild rye and put in fencing to scale back sand drift and defend fragile habitat.
How Sundown Dunes Was Constructed
Man standing in silhouette at Sundown Dunes Park, alongside the Pacific ocean, San Francisco, California
Town formally closed the highway to vehicles in March 2025 and started putting in park parts nearly instantly. As an alternative of utterly tearing out the present infrastructure, they tailored it. Visitors lights had been eliminated, some medians had been jackhammered to create space for facilities, and artwork installations had been funded by non-public donations. In all, the transformation price about $1 million, cut up evenly between private and non-private funds.
Volunteers performed a major position, serving to set up benches, paint murals, and organising playground gear. Wayfinding indicators had been added to information guests to native companies, and the park’s format was rigorously designed to incorporate “quick” and “gradual” zones, accommodating each joggers and households with youngsters. Though it’s solely been just a few months since its opening, Sundown Dunes is already town’s third-most-visited park on weekdays. Its fast and comparatively cheap rollout has turn into a case research in how massive cities can nonetheless ship significant civic enhancements with out ballooning budgets.
What’s Subsequent for Sundown Dunes?
Regardless of the native anger, Sundown Dunes isn’t going wherever—at the least not anytime quickly. Even when Joel Engardiowas recalled, the park would keep. Nevertheless, that hasn’t stopped efforts to reverse the closure of the roads. A lawsuit is already working its approach by the courts, and Richmond District Supervisor Connie Chan has floated the thought of a poll measure to reopen the freeway to vehicles. In the meantime, town is already planning the subsequent part of Sundown Dunes. A everlasting design, developed in coordination with the California Coastal Fee, will take erosion and sea stage rise under consideration. Emergency car entry will likely be retained, however the park may even see even much less pavement and extra inexperienced area sooner or later.
Neighborhood occasions have gotten a fixture within the park. An Easter egg hunt introduced in 10,000 attendees, and the upcoming Fourth of July parade is predicted to attract 1000’s extra. Organizers additionally plan to increase the “Nice Hauntway,” a Halloween celebration began through the pandemic.
- Inhabitants
-
39.35 Million ( 2020)
- Based Date
-
September 9, 1850
Some locals who initially opposed the venture are starting to ease up. Households are gathering, companies are thriving, and site visitors patterns are slowly stabilizing, which has satisfied just a few skeptics that possibly the trade-offs had been price it. As one neighbor put it, “I’m nonetheless aggravated concerning the site visitors—however I’m out right here with my youngsters each weekend now.”
The controversy over Sundown Dunes displays a deeper stress in city life—balancing progress with preservation, vehicles with neighborhood wants, and outdated methods with new concepts. For a lot of Sundown District residents, the ache of change feels private and political. However for metropolis planners and park advocates, Sundown Dunes represents a uncommon civic victory—a public area constructed rapidly, affordably, and with goal.
Recent Comments